Best Gutter Guards Consumer Reports

10 Best Gutter Guards Consumer Reports of 2022

If you don’t frequently clear your gutters, they’ll get clogged and allow water into your property. Gutter guards are an excellent option for homeowners who would rather not constantly risk injury by climbing a ladder to clean their gutters. Products like these don’t do away with routine maintenance entirely, but they do make it much more manageable.

The experts at This Old House have collated their findings on the best gutter guards on the market. Here, you’ll find detailed comparisons of our top eight suggestions.

Top 10 Gutter Guards Consumer Reports: Editor Recommended

The 10 Best Gutter Guards Consumer Reports Review:

1. Raptor Gutter Guard: A Contractor-Grade DIY Gutter Cover

Contractor-Grade DIY Gutter Cover
  • Stainless steel micro-mesh blocks leaves, pine needles and roof grit from...
  • Heavy-duty materials withstand all the elements and will never rust or warp.
  • Easy to install on any 5" wide or smaller gutter and won't void your roof...
  • Designed, Assembled and Packaged in the USA. Backed by 25-year warranty and a...
  • Includes self-tapping, corrosion-resistant screws, and a magnetic hex head...

This gutter guard is made of stainless steel and has a tiny yet sturdy mesh that prevents even the tiniest wind-blown seeds from entering your gutters. A sturdy micro-mesh cover slides under the roof’s underlayment and screws to the gutter for further safety. Raptor’s V-bend technique increases filtering efficiency and gives the mesh more stiffness, making it less likely to sag in the face of debris.

The Raptor gutter cover is designed to fit 5-inch gutters and is available in 48-foot lengths of manageable 5-foot strips. The strips, along with the necessary screws and nut-driver socket, are packaged for easy assembly.

We found the Raptor system to be an effective DIY gutter guard choice because of the flexibility it provides in terms of installation (across the gutter or beneath the shingles, as needed). Even with sharp scissors, we had a hard time slicing through the stainless steel, which speaks something about its durability. Expected debris was collected by the stainless steel mesh, which is also easily removed for gutter cleaning.


  • Stainless steel mesh
  • Flexible mounting styles
  • Easy to remove for cleaning


  • Very difficult to cut, even with good snips

Buy on Amazon

2. Frost King VX620 6″x20′ Plastic Gutter Guard

Plastic Gutter Guard
  • Keeps leaves and debris from clogging gutters
  • Will not rust or corrode
  • Cut to length with a Pair of ordinary scissors and quickly installed
  • 6" x 0.185" x 20 Feet in Length flexible plastic mesh Gutter guard
  • Can be easily unrolled

If you’d rather not spend a fortune on stainless steel, this Frost King gutter guard from Thermwell is a great plastic alternative that will protect your gutters free of huge debris and pests like mice and birds. The gutter guard is made of a plastic screen that measures 6 inches wide by 20 feet long, and it can be easily trimmed to suit any gutter using regular scissors.

The gutter guard requires no fasteners for assembly or installation. A guard can be easily installed in the gutter by bending its center upward so that it points toward the gutter’s outlet rather than generating a trough in which debris can accumulate. The gutters will be safe from damage throughout the year thanks to the plastic material’s resistance to rust and corrosion as well as moderate resistance to temperature variations.

Despite its low price, the Thermwell Frost King system performed well in tests. Since the plastic is so light, we had no trouble lifting 4- and 5-foot sections of screen up a ladder from the ground (which can be a challenge with heavier materials). But since they don’t require any fasteners, we found these gutter guards to be a little tricky to set up properly.


  • Easy to cut
  • Very affordable
  • Lightweight


  • Finicky to install

Buy on Amazon

3. GutterBrush Gutter Guard Simple DIY Leaf Filter Gutter Protection

DIY Leaf Filter Gutter Protection
  • 5 Inch Wide X 6 Ft Long Gutter Protection | Trial Pack - Easy DIY slide-in...
  • GutterBrush: The Original Since 2004 | Gutterbrush has 5 size diameters (see...
  • Year-Round Gutter Protection For Any Climate | DIY Gutter Guard, the easiest...
  • Protects Underground Drainage From Gutter Leaves | Easy leaf guard filter, no...
  • Save Time and Money On Gutter Cleaning | Stops gutter clogging, is easy to...

This gutter guard includes a bendable wire core made of stainless steel, so it can be installed in tight spaces. The UV-resistant polypropylene brush bristles reach roughly 4.5 inches from the core, making the whole gutter guard a snug fit in gutters of the typical size (5 inches).

Gutter guard is available in lengths between 6 and 120 feet and requires no tools or fasteners to install. Gutter guards are easy to install; just drop them in and give them a little push down until they reach the gutter’s base. While leaves, branches, and other heavy material are kept out of the gutter by the bristles, water can still freely flow through.

According to our tests, the most attractive feature of the GutterBrush gutter guard system is its simple setup. This gutter protection system is the most flexible of those we tried because it can be installed with either fascia or shingle-mounted brackets. They let in a lot of water, but we noticed that they can get clogged up with bigger things. We discovered that the GutterBrush isn’t a maintenance-free option, despite the fact that large debris is simple to remove.


  • Incredibly easy to install
  • Universal fit
  • Allows plenty of waterflow


  • Will definitely clog eventually

Buy on Amazon

4. Superior Gutter Guards | NEW Raised Stainless-Steel Screen Technology Gutter Cover

Stainless-Steel Screen Technology Gutter Cover
  • Superior Protects your Gutters, Handles the Harshest of Weather conditions,...
  • Superior Gutter Guards Blocks Creepy-crawlies, Flying Insects, Pests, Birds,...
  • Made to protect your Family, Home, Foundation, Using Stainless Steel Mesh, Mill...
  • Constructed to DIY, Installs Easily and Quick. Our Mission is to do it Right the...
  • A Trusted Company Engineered and Built in USA, Superior Gutter Guards has Your...

Protect your gutters from debris like leaves, sticks, mud, and grime with this micro-mesh gutter guard made of long-lasting stainless steel. The guard’s strong metal frame glides beneath the initial course of shingles, while the other half of the guard rests on the gutter’s outside edge. Installing a gutter guard will provide year-round protection for your roof and gutters from debris and rain.

This 48-foot long gutter guard system is constructed to fit regular 5-inch gutters. Water is channeled into the gutter below the guard while debris slides over the top thanks to the mesh’s raised pattern. Debris can more easily slide or be blown off the guard if it is set at the same slope inclination as the roof.

The quality of construction of Superior Gutter Guards is far above that of the alternatives. They are strong and not overly difficult to saw through. Furthermore, the micro mesh’s elevated design provided the impression of increased strength. These gutter guards are among the most effective because they are unlikely to collect debris. Despite the manufacturer’s claims of multiple mounting choices, we were only successful in installing the guards under the shingle, where they were clearly visible from the street.


  • Debris washes off easily
  • Appears to be the most effective option
  • Very durable


  • A little confusing to install
  • Visible from the ground

Buy on Amazon

5. FlexxPoint 30 Year Gutter Cover System, Residential 5″ Gutter Guards

30 Year Gutter Cover System
  • Available in White, Matte Aluminum, Thermal Thaw Black and Brown. Now made from...
  • Easy to Install, Contractor pricing, Includes 1/2" #8 Stainless Steel Zip...
  • Cannot be seen from the ground, Blocks all types of debris. Clog free, High...
  • Does NOT void roof warranties, Permanently installs, Easy to handle 4 foot...
  • Now with STAINLESS STEEL fastners, Factory Direct, Made in the USA

In the event of significant leaf or snow accumulation, the FlexxPoint 5″ Gutter Cover System will not sag or collapse. It’s made from rustproof metal and has raised ridges along its length for added strength. There is no way to tell from the ground that the screen gutter guard is there.

The provided screws allow you to securely fasten this gutter guard to the outer edge of your gutter. There’s no need to sneak it beneath the shingles because it just snaps into position. It is offered in 22-, 102-, 125-, 200-, and 204-foot lengths, with a number of different colors (black, white, brown, and matte).

The FlexxPoint Gutter Cover System excelled in tests due to a number of its unique characteristics. This method was unique in that screws were needed in both the front and back of the gutter. Because of this, it is incredibly sturdy and secure; it won’t fall out on its own. And despite its toughness, it may be easily shaped with a knife. As a heavy-duty guard, its invisibility from the ground is a tremendous asset. Larger debris, however, is collected and needs to be removed manually (although easily).


  • Very heavy duty
  • Super-secure installation system
  • Invisible from the ground


  • It can clog and require attention

Buy on Amazon

6. A-M Aluminum Gutter Guard 5 inch

Aluminum Gutter Guard 5 inch
  • The Difference is In the Design. Heavy (Industrial) Gauge .018 100% Aluminum...
  • Designed specifically for hidden hangars but works with all hangars including...
  • Virtually invisible from the ground
  • Designed to handle downpours with 380 holes per linear foot
  • Easy to install with tabs for seamless joints. Requires 1/2" #8 Zip Screws - not...

The A-M Gutter Guard Aluminum 5″ Gutter Guard is a great option for those who don’t want their gutter guards to be seen from below. The perforated panel is 380 holes per linear foot and is made of aluminum suitable for industrial use, making it capable of withstanding intense rainfall. Nothing will detract from the aesthetic value of a roof because it fits neatly inside the top of the gutter and is nearly invisible once installed.

The panel’s tabs make it simple to slip it under the shingles, and it fastens to the gutter’s lip with self-tapping screws (not included). It fits 5-inch gutters and is offered in 23, 50, 100, and 200-foot lengths. There are 23-foot, 50-foot, and 200-foot options for the 6-inch gutter version of this product.

When we tested the A-M Gutter Guard system, we found ourselves with mixed feelings. These metal gutter guards are an excellent system, as they are not visible from the ground and have sturdy reinforcement ridges along their length.

It does a fantastic job of enabling waterflow and collecting trash, and it is easy to cut and install, even around brackets. Unfortunately, self-tapping screws are not included. If a system needed a fastener, it had one. In addition, heavier particles will block this system, necessitating some maintenance.


  • Easy to cut
  • Invisible from the ground
  • Durable reinforcement ridges


  • Can clog with larger debris
  • Screws not included

Buy on Amazon

7. Amerimax Home Products 636025 Lock-In Gutter Guard

Lock-In Gutter Guard
  • Compatible with 4", 5", and 6" metal (steel or aluminum) K-style gutters
  • The tight expanded metal mesh pattern keeps out most debris, to keep your...
  • Constructed of durable powder-coated steel for long life and protection from the...
  • Easy "lock-in" installation, simply slide under the first row of shingles and...
  • Includes 10-year limited

The Amerimax Home Products Lock-In Gutter Guard is designed to be installed quickly and easily by anyone, even if they have never done it before. This screen-style gutter guard can be installed by sliding it under the first row of shingles and snapping it over the gutter’s outer edge. It can be used with gutters of any size, including 4, 5, and 6 inches.

The Amerimax Home Products gutter guard is made of powder-coated steel that is resistant to rust and will keep leaves and debris out of your gutters without blocking the flow of even the heaviest rain. It’s a breeze to install and comes in manageable 3-foot-long strips.

Because the hardware-free installation worked so well in testing and was so secure, removing the gutter guard by hand was a bit of a chore. We were able to place the screen in a variety of ways (as we were unable to fit it under our shingles, we hung it across the top of the gutter). It accomplished its job of blocking larger pieces of debris, but some smaller ones got through. The only difficulty in removing the protection was caused by the cut mesh becoming caught on the brackets.


  • Flexible installation options
  • Locking design works well
  • Easy to cut


  • Installing around brackets can be difficult
  • Removing can be difficult

Buy on Amazon

8. Gutter Guard by Gutterglove 4 ft. Stainless Steel 5 in. Micro-Mesh Gutter Guard

The Gutterglove is one of the best gutter guards for preventing debris like leaves and pine needles from clogging your gutters. Additionally, they can eliminate microscopic insects and grit from your roof.

Gutterglove makes a micro-mesh gutter guard that is available in shorter pieces of 4 feet, which is perfect if you simply need a little protection but don’t want to spend a fortune. Even though a bundle of that length is available for purchase, the price may rise significantly.

This is another another hassle-free set-up method. Even though the gutter guard can be installed with the 3M tape provided, we advise using the self-tapping screws for added security.


  • Comes with all installation hardware
  • Micro-mesh
  • Comes in smaller panels


  • Larger package is expensive

Buy on Amazon

9. GutterBrush Gutter Guard for 5 Inch and 6 Inch Gutters

Gutter Guard for 5 Inch and 6 Inch Gutters
  • 5 Inch Wide X 30 Ft Long Gutter Protection | Easy DIY slide-in Gutter Guard...
  • GutterBrush: The Original Since 2004 | Gutterbrush has 5 size diameters (see...
  • Year-Round Gutter Protection For Any Climate | DIY Gutter Guard, the easiest...
  • Protects Underground Drainage From Gutter Leaves | Easy leaf guard filter, no...
  • Save Time and Money On Gutter Cleaning | Stops gutter clogging, is easy to...

A gutter guard brush operates on a straightforward principle: A brush with firm bristles is placed inside the gutter to prevent the accumulation of leaves, pine needles, insects, and other potentially problematic waste. When the bush is in place, precipitation can easily pass through without being impeded.

A brush’s convenience lies in the fact that it can be placed in the gutter without the need of any instruments. This brush comes in a variety of widths and lengths and even comes with a handy size guide. A brush may collect leaves and other debris, but it will still save you time and effort in the long run because it will prevent as much gunk from building up in your gutters. Furthermore, you might think your gutter is blocked, even when water is flowing freely underneath.


  • Simple to install
  • No hardware or tools needed
  • Rainwater flows freely


  • Expensive
  • Debris accumulates on top
  • Can be unsightly over time

Buy on Amazon

10. Amerimax Home Products 638010 Hoover Dam Gutter Guard, Dark Gray

Hoover Dam Gutter Guard
  • Compatible with 4", 5", and 6" metal (steel or aluminum) K-style gutters. Style:...
  • Designed to handle the heaviest of debris and keep out all types from broadleaf...
  • The innovative "dam" design keeps the heaviest of rainfall flowing into the...
  • Constructed of durable powder-coated steel for long life and protection from the...
  • Easy installation, simply slide under the first row of shingles and screw the...

The Amerimax Hoover Dam Gutter Guard is an effective solution for preventing huge leaves from clogging your gutter. This guard is constructed with a dam-like form and many ridges to direct water down the gutter during heavy downpours and to allow accumulated leaves to dry out and be blown away. All standard 4-, 5-, and 6-inch K-style gutters can use these protectors.

These panels are made from durable powder-coated steel and are 3 feet in length and about 7 inches in width. Simply slide the guard under the first row of shingles and secure the panel to the front lip of the gutter with self-tapping screws if you want to do the installation yourself. The guards are backed by a 15-year guarantee and are an excellent choice for homes in leafy areas.


  • Dam design holds up to heavy rainfall
  • Fits several gutter sizes
  • Blends in with roofline
  • Easy to install


  • Fairly expensive
  • Fine debris can fall through

Buy on Amazon

Buying Guide: What To Look For in a Gutter Guard

a) Type 

Gutter guards come in several forms, such as screen, micro-mesh, reverse-curve, and foam. Screen gutter guards are made up of narrow slats of a mesh-like material, typically made of PVC or metal, that prevent big debris from entering the gutters while yet allowing water to flow freely. Products made with micro-mesh are very similar, except that the holes are exceedingly tiny and can filter out even the tiniest dust and dirt.

Metal or PVC reverse-curve gutter guards employ surface tension to send water into the gutter through a tiny opening while keeping debris out. Last but not least, foam gutter guards may be installed in a jiffy because they are constructed of long pieces of foam that are only placed into your gutter.

b) Material

Gutter guards can be found in a wide range of materials, from vinyl and aluminum to sponge and steel. There are advantages and disadvantages to each substance. Jeff Beck, Chief Growth Officer of Leaf Home Solutions, suggests steel or aluminum over vinyl if you care primarily about longevity. Rainwater can soak through sponge protection, while heavier particles can simply fall away. While sponge guards are inexpensive, Beck warns that flaws in them make debris accumulation more likely.

c) Ease of Installation

Even though gutter guards are an expensive addition to your home, you can save money by putting them up on your own. Gutter guards can be easily installed with a screwdriver or clips from a variety of manufacturers. However, the cost of your project may increase if you need a professional to install a more complex system, such as heating wires.

d) Visibility

You can see the gutter guard you have installed if it extends above your gutter. This type of gutter protection is typically a reverse-curve or micro-mesh design that fastens to the gutter’s edge. Inside-the-gutter brush and foam gutter guards are less obvious. Gutter covers made of plastic painted to match your gutters are one option for a streamlined aesthetic when installing gutter covers.


Protecting your gutters from debris buildup and pest infestations using gutter guards is a great method to minimize gutter maintenance. The following are answers to some of the most frequently asked questions regarding gutter guards, including how they function and how they should be maintained.

i) Q: Do gutter guards go under shingles?

Gutter guards come in a wide variety of styles and materials, and their installation can range from above the roof to under the first or second row of shingles.

ii) Q: Do gutter guards work in heavy rain?

Most gutter guards will be fine in heavy rain, though ones clogged with debris, such as leaves or sticks, may have trouble with the fast-moving water. During the spring and fall, when falling debris from neighboring foliage is at its worst, it is crucial to inspect and clean the gutters and the guards.

iii) Q: Do gutter guards cause ice dams?

Because they prevent snow and ice from melting, gutter guards like reverse-curve guards can make ice dams even more of a problem. However, most gutter guards aid in avoiding ice development by restricting the quantity of snow that enters the gutters.


To prevent water damage to your home, you need gutter guards that filter out debris effectively. Gutter guards can lessen the frequency with which gutters need to be cleaned, but they cannot remove them altogether. To get the best expert installation, we think LeafFilter is your best bet. We also recommend HomeCraft because of its cutting-edge diamond-raised technology. At last, American Gutter Protection offers an excellent guard system that can be tailored to your home and comes in a wide variety of colors.

At least three gutter guard options should be compared to discover the best one for your gutters. Find local gutter guard installers using the handy map below.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *