Best Toilets Consumer Reports

10 Best Toilets Consumer Reports of 2022 – Review and Buying Guide

There’s a lot of potential for toilet humor here, but picking out a new one for your house is no laughing matter, what with all the flushing it’ll be doing and the potentially disastrous outcomes if you pick out a dud. A toilet with insufficient flushing power may cause frequent clogs, which will cause major plumbing problems in your home. There are models that can leave unattractive stains, and others whose flushes would wake the whole house if you need to use them in the middle of the night.

Some of the conclusions drawn from decades of testing by the Good Housekeeping Institute’s experts on the subject of toilets are as follows. Our engineers have run extensive experiments to identify models that optimally balance performance and efficiency for this current iteration. This compilation is made up of previous top-performing models, road tests of newer equipment, and manufacturers with proven track records, just like the blenders, dehumidifiers, and sewing machines we review. Here are 2022’s top-rated restroom facilities.

Top 10 Toilets Consumer Reports: Editor Recommended

The 10 Best Toilets Consumer Reports Review:

1. KOHLER 3814-0 Two (TM) Corbelle Comfort Height(R) Elongated 1.28 gpf Toilet

Comfort Height(R) Elongated 1.28 gpf Toilet
  • Two-piece toilet
  • Elongated bowl offers added room and comfort
  • Skirted Trapway simplifies cleaning
  • Revolution 360 swirl flushing technology generates a forceful swirling motion to...
  • Comfort Height feature offers chair-height seating that makes sitting down and...

The Kohler Corbelle Comfort Height Toilet is a high-quality option for anyone looking for a toilet from a reputable manufacturer. It’s sleek and contemporary, with details like a vertical brushed nickel handle, and it’s quite tall. To complement a wide range of existing bathroom color schemes, it comes in a wide range of neutral tones.

The single-flush gravity and swirl flushing technology in this two-piece toilet, which Kohler claims helps keep the bowl cleaner for longer, provides powerful flushing action. This toilet is more accessible and comfortable due to the comfort-height seat, which is at chair height. The CleanCoat surface coating and skirted trapway, in addition to the higher seat and longer bowl, make routine cleaning a breeze.

This toilet, while functional and well-made, is more expensive than some alternatives. Sadly, you’ll have to shell out extra cash for a toilet seat. There have been reports of problems from some property owners. However, if you do run into any problems with your Corbelle, the manufacturer provides a limited guarantee that will cover things like cracks, leaks, and more for a full year.

Pros:

  • Affordably priced
  • Uses less water
  • Slow-close seat
  • Available in elongated or round bowl

Cons:

  • Small and flimsy flush handle
  • More crevices to clean

Buy on Amazon

2. Kohler 3810-0 Santa Rosa Comfort Height Elongated

Santa Rosa Comfort Height Elongated
  • One piece toilets integrate the tank and bowl into a seamless, easy to clean...
  • Compact elongated bowl offers added comfort while occupying the same space as a...
  • Comfort height: Feature offers chair height seating that makes sitting down and...
  • Standard left hand trip lever included
  • 1.28 gallons per flush (gpf)

The Kohler Santa Rosa is typical of one-piece toilets in that it is both aesthetically pleasing and space-efficient. This toilet has a seamless design from the tank to the bowl, making it simple to keep clean and in good working order. Garbage, both solid and liquid, is swiftly flushed away by the powerful gravity-fed flush. AquaPiston technology fills the bowl from every angle to make sure nothing is missed.

The height of the rim when the seat is installed is greater than 17 inches. This is an excellent option for elderly homeowners or those with mobility challenges due to the comfort height and the extra-long seat. For those who are sensitive to noise, you should know that this toilet does not have a slow-closing lid.

Pros:

  • Powerful flush
  • 360-degree rinse with each flush
  • One-piece design is easier to clean

Cons:

  • On the pricier side
  • Doesn’t have a soft-close lid

Buy on Amazon

3. American Standard Single Flush Right Height Round Front Toilet

Single Flush Right Height Round Front Toilet
  • Combination bowl and tank, with seat
  • 12" (305 mm) rough-in
  • High efficiency, ultra-low consumption (1.28 gpf/4.8 Lpf), utilizes 20% less...
  • Meets EPA WaterSense criteria
  • 16-1/2" (419 mm) rim height for accessible application

American Standard has been a leader in the toilet-manufacturing industry for almost 140 years, and the Cadet 3 FloWise is one of its top-rated models. The extra height and the expanded seat on this two-piece toilet make it simpler to maneuver—an perfect alternative for someone with limited mobility. Thanks to EverClean technology that keeps mold and mildew at bay, the bowl interior will stay clean and shining. It includes a slow-close seat and lid which, together with the gravity-flush mechanism, keeps noise to a minimum. The Cadet 3 FloWise is a high-efficiency, ultra-low consumption toilet; it uses roughly 20% less water than standard types.

In general, the negative to a two-piece design is that there are more gaps and crevices to clean. There are a few issues to consider regarding this particular model: The little handle might be finicky and the flushing force is a touch weak. You may have to hold the handle down for a bit to properly flush, or flush it twice.

Pros:

  • EverClean technology
  • Slow-close seat and lid
  • Quiet operation
  • Less water use

Cons:

  • Finicky handle
  • Slightly weak flushing power
  • More crevices to clean

Buy on Amazon

4. Glacier Bay 1-piece 1.1 GPF/1.6 GPF High Efficiency Dual Flush Elongated

Water conservation is an added bonus of Glacier Bay’s dual-flush toilet. You can choose between a partial flush for liquid waste and a full flush for solid waste using the two buttons at the top of the tank. Its 16.5-inch height is right between what is considered standard and what is considered comfortable, and its stretched seat contributes to this sensation.

It’s more streamlined, takes up less room, and is less of a hassle to clean thanks to its one-piece design and tank-to-bowl construction. It comes in the standard white, bone, black, and biscuit hues. Some consumers have experienced problems with their new toilets right out of the box; if this is the case, they should take advantage of the manufacturer’s lifetime warranty.

Pros:

  • Dual-flush technology
  • Uses less water
  • Comes in four different colors
  • One-piece design is easier to clean

Cons:

  • Reports of defective products

Buy on Amazon

5. TOTO WASHLET+ Carlyle II One-Piece Elongated 1.28 GPF Toilet

One-Piece Elongated 1.28 GPF Toilet
  • WASHLET+ bidet seat and toilet, specially designed to conceal the WASHLET water...
  • Hands free automatic flush system
  • EWATER+ mists the wand and toilet bowl, reducing the need for harsh cleaning...
  • Front and rear warm water washing with five adjustable temperature and pressure...
  • Auto open/close lid and heated seat, automatic air deodorizer, nightlight, and...

The Carlyle II Washlet melds the best features of a bidet and a modern toilet. A strong cyclonic rinse technology helps conserve water and keep the bowl fresh. The integrated toilet seat has a variety of convenient features, such as a deodorizer, a warm air dryer, a remote control, temperature controls for both the water and the seat, and a wand that cleans the toilet without the need for any human intervention. In order to facilitate cleaning, the toilet has been coated with a special ceramic glaze that prevents dirt and grime from adhering to its surface.

It’s not surprising that a product with so many high-end features would cost more than the average toilet, but this TOTO bidet is actually rather reasonably priced. Utilities will be cheaper in the long term because to the toilets’ low water consumption (1 gallon every flush).

Pros:

  • Powerful flush
  • Low water use
  • Adjustable temperature and pressure
  • Heated seat
  • Warm air dryer

Cons:

  • Expensive

Buy on Amazon

6. Nature’s Head Self Contained Composting Toilet

Head Self Contained Composting Toilet
  • No one - and I mean no one - will beat my customer service and individual...
  • Easy to install by any reasonably handy person.
  • Absolutely No Odor. No Maintenance. 5 Year Warranty.
  • Huge Capacity. 2 people using full time will empty every 4-6 weeks. Easy empty...
  • A vast improvement over older composting toilet designs. This one works!

Rather than flushing the waste away, a composting toilet stores the waste until it can be removed. Nature Heat’s top-rated product is trusted and simple to operate. There is a spider handle on the side of the garbage can that can be used to stir the trash inside the can as it is removed. This compositing toilet’s capacity is exceptionally high in comparison to similar types. Two people can live comfortably with it, and it needs to be emptied every four to six weeks.

You may rest assured that this composting toilet will keep your bathroom smelling fresh. A built-in electric fan helps to remove unpleasant odors. The fan is powered by 12 volts, but a 110 volt conversion kit is available for purchase from the maker.

Pros:

  • Large capacity
  • Lightweight and portable
  • Venting fan eliminates odors

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • Seat isn’t very comfortable

Buy on Amazon

7. WOODBRIDGE B-0960S 1.0 1.6 GPF Dual Toilet

B-0960S 1.0 1.6 GPF Dual Toilet
  • [TOTALLY HYGIENIC]: Posterior wash, Feminine wash, Pulsating wash, Adjustable...
  • [AUTOMATIC FLUSH]: the seat will activate the self-cleaning bidet/spray wand and...
  • [AUTO OPEN AND CLOSED]: Smart toilet features begin as you approach the toilet....
  • [AIR PURIFICATION]: The deodorizer effectively cleans the air around the toilet...
  • [HIGH EFFICIENCY FLUSH] Quiet and powerful Siphonic 1.6 GPF/1.0 GPF dual...

Woodbridge’s high-tech toilet includes numerous advanced features for superior cleanliness. Your approach triggers the lid to open, and your exit triggers the flush. The heated seat will keep you warm and comfortable on cold days. The bidet function provides a customizable wash for both the front and back. The remote allows you to adjust all of these settings for your own comfort. This state-of-the-art lavatory has a deodorizer and air dryer that do away with the need for toilet paper altogether.

Obviously, the cost of such a high-tech toilet would be quite high. However, its level of comfort is unparalleled. This toilet weighs in at a hefty 140 pounds, making installation a more involved process.

Pros:

  • Hands-free operation
  • Heated seat and warm air dryer
  • Automatic air deodorizer
  • Wireless remote control

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • Extremely heavy

Buy on Amazon

8. Camco Portable Toilet, 2.6 Gallons

Portable Toilet 2.6 Gallons
  • Portable Travel Toilet: This portable camping toilet is designed for camping,...
  • Sturdy Design: Its sturdy polyethylene construction is compact and lightweight;...
  • Leak-Proof: This camp toilet comes with a sealing slide valve to lock in odors...
  • Easy to Use: The camping portable toilet employs an easy-to-use bellow-type...
  • Quality Products: Camco makes quality products for RVing, boating, camping,...

Whether you’re going camping, boating, or doing something else outdoors, Camco has a portable toilet that will make your experience more comfortable. It just only 11 pounds, but its sturdy construction means it can hold up to 330 pounds. A pair of carry handles are built in at the top and bottom for convenience.

The bowl, lid, and seat are all stored in the top part of the flush tank, which can hold up to 2.5 gallons of clean water. The flush tank can be refilled with fresh water by removing the cap located on top of the fixture. The 5.3 gallon holding tank may be removed and has a closing slide valve to keep in smells and prevent leaks.

Overall, this device does a fantastic job of containing trash without making a mess. In addition to the plastic parts cracking with time and perhaps leaking, the seat may be too narrow for some.

Pros:

  • Lightweight
  • Built-in handles for easy carrying
  • Easy-to-empty waste tank
  • Designed to seal in odors

Cons:

  • Seat is on the smaller side
  • Plastic is prone to breakage

Buy on Amazon

9. Swiss Madison Well Made Forever SM-1T254 St. Tropez One Piece Toilet

Tropez One Piece Toilet
  • Modern design, clean, sleek look and compliment with different styles
  • Fully skirted trapway - extremely easy to clean
  • Sleek and eye appealing modern design
  • Soft closing seat included
  • Special holes to reach the bolts - includes bolt caps and wax ring

This toilet is sleek and eye-catching. It would look good in any modern style, from mid-century to minimalist. But the Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece Elongated Toilet is more than just an interesting design—also it’s a full-featured one-piece toilet with thoughtful features that make it easy to install and clean.

The Swiss Madison St. Tropez toilet has a dual-flush system, a long handle, and clear buttons. It also has a long seat and a 16-inch bowl height, which makes it sit a little higher than usual. The seat has chrome hinges that come off easily so it can be cleaned or replaced, and the lid closes softly so it won’t slam in the middle of the night.

The two flushes (1.1 and 1.6 gallons) use a “Vortex” system with two nozzles that force more water against the inside of the rim. This helps keep the bowl cleaner. The inside of the bowl is also glazed and shiny to make it easy to clean.

The Swiss Madison St. Tropez comes in many different finishes, such as matte black, matte white, glossy white, and a color called “Bisque,” which is an off-white color.

Pros:

  • Soft close lid
  • Modern design, without nooks and crannies, ensures easy cleaning
  • Dual nozzles keep the bowl cleaner
  • Fully-skirted bowl
  • Wide variety of colors and finishes are available

Cons:

  • An ADA-compliant or “Comfort Height” version would be welcome

Buy on Amazon

10. KOHLER K-6299-0 Veil Wall-Hung Elongated Toilet Bowl

Veil Wall-Hung Elongated Toilet Bowl
  • One-piece wall-hung toilet
  • Compact elongated bowl offers added comfort while occupying the same space as a...
  • Mounting hardware is completely concealed, giving Veil a sleek, seamless look...
  • Includes wall-hung bowl with Grip Tight Reveal Q3 seat
  • Combines with the K-6284 In-Wall Tank and Carrier System to create a complete...

A wall-hung toilet, such as the sleek and sophisticated Kohler Veil Wall-Hung, can free up valuable floor space, make cleaning the basement lavatory a breeze, and improve the room’s aesthetics. A foot or more of floor space is reclaimed thanks to its small profile. As with any toilet, the elongated bowl doesn’t take up any more floor space than a regular round-front bowl unless it’s being mounted on the wall. What’s more, the bowl can be suspended at any height between 15 and 23 inches above the floor, depending on your own preference.

It’s important to know that some of the parts of a wall-mounted toilet are hidden away behind the drywall. The Kohler Veil lacks a flush actuator plate and an in-wall tank.

The quiet-close seat on the Kohler Veil Wall-Hung Toilet is available in four different colors (white, Biscuit, Dune, and “Black Black”). It satisfies federal guidelines for water efficiency and is ADA-compliant.

Buy on Amazon

Buying Guide: What to Consider When Choosing Toilet

a) Toilet style

There are three common styles of toilet:

  • One-piece: The toilet bowl and toilet tank are all one piece. is made of one seamless piece where the bowl is separate from the tank and must be bolted on during installation. Because they don’t have gaps between the bowl and tank, one-piece toilets are typically easier to clean. However, they are also heavier, which can make them trickier to install, since the entire toilet has to be lifted into place as one unit.
  • Two-piece: This is the traditional toilet design, with a water tank bolted on top of a lower bowl. Two-piece tanks are often more affordable, with a wide variety of options. You can even mix and match toilet bowls and tanks, for a little more customization.
  • Wall-Mount: Toilets that are mounted directly to the wall not only look sleek, but can save a lot of space in your bathroom. However, they are complex to install, requiring additional bracing, as well as plumbing modifications if you’re switching from a standard toilet.

b) Flush Type

There are two choices to consider for your toilet’s flush:

  • Single flush: This type of toilet uses the same amount of water for each flush and has a single mechanism for flushing. Single-flush toilets often have handles or levers, rather than buttons. Since they are more common and have standardized components, it’s often easier to buy replacement parts for single-flush toilets, and repair costs are typically cheaper. However, single-flush toilets can be more water wasteful.
  • Dual-flush: A dual-flush toilet uses two buttons, typically located on top of the tank, for two different types of flushing. One flush uses less water—typically less than a gallon per flush—and is meant for removing liquid waste. A second, larger flush is reserved for solid waste disposal.

c) Height

While the distance from the floor to the rim of your toilet bowl—often called the seat or bowl height—varies from model to model, there are two primary ranges into which bowl heights are grouped:

  • Standard Height: A standard height toilet has a rim that’s 14.5 to 16 inches from the floor. Shorter toilet seats may benefit bowel movements, since it puts people closer to a crouching position, straightening the colon. This may reduce the need for straining, and is the reason behind the popularity of position-adjusting products like the Squatty Potty.
  • Comfort Height (also known as Chair Height): Comfort height toilets are taller—typically 17 to 19 inches—making it so you don’t have to crouch as much to sit on them. While 16.125 and 16.5-inch toilet rim heights are sometimes described as comfort heights, the standard is most often associated with models approved by the Americans with Disabilities Act, with rims at least 16.5 inches off the ground.2

d) Bowl shape

Toilets and toilet seats are designed for two different bowl shapes:

  • Round: Round bowls are common to older toilets and are still available today. They are typically 16.5 inches from the tip of the bowl to the seat bolts. They provide a smaller opening but can save two inches of space compared to an elongated bowl. If your bathroom is especially cramped, a round bowl might be worth your consideration.
  • Elongated: In most bathrooms, people prefer elongated bowls, which are typically 18.5 inches long. They provide both a larger opening and a broader space for the toilet seat, making them more comfortable to sit on for most people. The only real downside to an elongated bowl is that it takes up more space, and may not fit in a smaller bathroom.

e) Flushing technology

Modern toilets typically use one of two different flushing technologies:

  • Gravity-Flush: These toilets hold water in a raised tank, then let gravity pull the volume of water down through the toilet bowl when you flush. It’s a simple, reliable mechanism that requires no additional assistance to operate. Most residential homes use gravity-flush toilets.
  • Pressure-Assisted: Pressure-assisted toilets store water for flushing inside of an airtight tank, then uses air pressure to push out the water through the bowl. This allows for a more powerful flush with less water used since it can force the water through the bowl at a higher speed than gravity. They’re much less likely to clog and can generate a powerful flush without wasting water. However, pressure-assisted flush toilets are typically more expensive and louder.

The majority of toilets use a gravity-flush system to force water and its contents out of the bowl. This type of flushing system is quiet and requires little maintenance, which is why it’s such a popular option.

However, there are newer styles of flushing systems, as well. For instance, you may come across pressure-assisted flushing technology, where pressurized air forces water into the bowl.

f) Water usage

You can stop worrying that your new toilet will be wasteful because of the rule that states it cannot use more than 1.6 gallons of water per flush. 3

High-efficiency toilets, however, consume just about 1.1 to 1.2 gallons of water per flush, conserving considerably more water. The “WaterSense” logo from the Environmental Protection Agency is a common way to recognize these high-efficiency products. 4

g) Noise level

To avoid disturbing sleep or waking a sleeping baby, think about how loud your new toilet is before installing it in a noisy location.

Some toilets have fill valves that are engineered to be quieter, and gravity-flush systems in general are the least noisy option. Additionally, a soft-close lid that keeps the lid from slamming shut is helpful if noise is a concern.

h) Appearance

After you’ve worked out the mechanics, you may think about how the new toilet will look in your bathroom. While white remains the most popular choice, models are also available in black, gray, tan, and even bright hues like pink and yellow.

The piping that curves behind the bowl of a toilet, known as the trapway, also comes in a variety of configurations. The bends will be evident if you choose for a model that has open trapways, so keep that in mind. A toilet with buried or skirted trapways, in which these turns are hidden, can save you some cleaning time and give your bathroom a more streamlined appearance.

i) Size

Determine the “rough-in” measurement, or the distance from the wall to the floor drain, of the old toilet you plan to replace.

Rough-ins are typically 12 inches apart, however older homes may only have 10 or 14 inches. With this number in hand, you’ll be able to select a toilet with confidence that it will fit in your bathroom’s plumbing.

j) Special features

You can find toilets with more functions, but they usually come at a higher price.

Some types, for instance, include touchless flushing, allowing you to flush with a wave of the hand. There are also self-cleaning capabilities, bidet functions, night illumination, overflow protection, and heated seats. However, these additions may drive up the price of your new toilet and may increase the amount of servicing it needs over its lifetime.

FAQs

i) How should you measure for a new toilet?

When looking for a new toilet, the rough-in (the distance from the wall to the center of the drainpipe or the bolts that secure the toilet to the floor) is the most crucial dimension to consider. Rough-in sizes range from 10 to 14 inches, with the industry standard being 12 inches. In order to determine the maximum dimensions of the new toilet, you must first measure the available floor space.

How do you install a new toilet?

The first step in installing a new toilet is to remove the old one and either fix or replace its flange (if needed). To make sure the bolts fit into the holes in the base and the toilet is level, you should set it on top of the flange for a test fit. Next, replace the wax seal around the horn, position the toilet, secure the nuts, and hook up the water line.

ii) What’s the best way to unclog a toilet?

Toilet plungers (also known as flanged plungers or closet plungers) are effective for clearing out most clogs, but a cup plunger won’t do the trick. To clear a clog in a toilet, place the cup of the plunger over the drain opening at the base of the bowl and lower the plunger into the bowl at an angle. Here, you can give the plunger a few hard whacks to generate enough pressure to break through the blockage. If you have a good seal, most clogs can be eliminated with just five or six thrusts.

iii) How often should you clean your toilet?

A toilet should have its bowl and seat cleaned at least once or twice weekly to maintain hygiene. However, if several people are using it, you may need to clean it more often.

iv) Should you hire a plumber to install your toilet?

Anyone with access to common home improvement tools and a basic understanding of plumbing can install a toilet. Detailed instructions for even the most basic of installations can be found on the websites of manufacturers, hardware stores, and other retailers. Before you begin removing the old toilet, always turn off the water supply. It’s probably a good idea to have a spouse help out with the heavy lifting involved in replacing a toilet.

There are, of course, instances in which you may want to hire a plumber to help you put in a new toilet. Installation of a wall-mounted toilet, for example, is beyond the skill set of the average do-it-yourselfer. In addition, homeowners of older properties may want to think about hiring a plumber in case they run into problems when trying to install a new toilet according to modern guidelines.

Conclusion

For its powerful flush and comfortable, easy-to-clean design, the Kohler Corbelle Comfort Height Toilet (see at Amazon) comes out on top. Although more expensive than standard two-piece commodes, this model does not skimp on quality or style. The Delta Foundations 2-Piece Toilet is an affordable option (view at Home Depot). This toilet has a slow-close seat and a splash guard, making it an excellent value despite its modest price.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *